Pricing

Here you will find my pricing and information related to each custom cookie package.

All cookies are made with a sugar cookie base and vanilla royal icing, unless otherwise specified to be a flavor I offer.

Please keep in mind:

A non-refundable 50% deposit is required to secure your booking and is due upon receipt of invoice.
Unless otherwise requested, each cookie is individually heat-sealed in a food-safe cellophane bag to maintain freshness for up to three weeks @ room temperature. Cookies are labeled with ingredients either individually or on the box.
Cookies are often dusted with cornstarch prior to packaging to prevent the cookies from sticking to their bags. It is food-safe and does not alter the taste and, while I do my best to remove any excess, some may be visible on the cookies or in their bags.
Glitter/shimmer accents, dusts, paints, and marker details are all FDA approved and 100% edible.

How the order process works

Check my calendar to see if your event date is available. I typically need at least 3 weeks notice on any cookie order, so please be sure to reach out early! That said, feel free to email me to verify availability due to schedule changes.
Select the "Cookie Order Form" below and fill out all the specific form questions, so that I can get you an accurate quote.
You'll get an email confirmation of your submission, and I'll send you a formal quote within 1-2 days once I understand what your needs are.
You'll approve the quote via the link in your email, and pay the 50% non-refundable deposit to reserve your slot on my calendar.
2 weeks before the order is due, you'll pay the balance - I do not start on orders until full balance is received - you'll receive email reminders for payment, so please add admin@mycustombakes.com to your "safe" list, and don't forget to check your spam folder.
When your order is ready for pickup/delivery, I'll send you a text message and we'll coordinate the delivery details.
Enjoy your delicious cookies with family and/or friends and be sure to let me know how you liked them and leave a review! :)

For any other questions about ordering, payments/refunds, deposits, etc, please check out my Terms & Conditions.

Thank You!

Cookie Order Form

Basic Sugar Cookies

Minimum of 1 dozen required.
1-3 basic cookie designs.
1-3 icing colors, plus white.
Standard size cookie, approximately 3-4" @ the longest edge.
Starting price: $45/dozen

This is perfect if you want custom cookies, but don't need a ton of designs or details!

Example photo:

Detailed Sugar Cookies
(Most Popular!)

Minimum of 1 dozen required.
Up to 6 basic cookie designs (6+ is an upcharge).
Up to 6 icing colors, plus white (6+ is an upcharge).
Standard size cookie, approximately 3-4" @ the longest edge.
Starting price: $54/dozen

This is the most popular design option! Added details may include floral accents, airbrushing, painting, and characters* (see footnote).

Example photo:

Mini Sugar Cookies

Mini decorated sugar cookies have a basic design (or plainly flooded in a color of your choosing).
Average size is 2" @ the longest edge.
These cookies work well as accent cookies in a large order.
Minimum 2 dozen required.
Starting price: $28/dozen

*As of June 2025 I will no longer offer character cookies that are not public domain, due to copyright and trademark laws. I can, however, make a custom set inspired by a particular character or movie...which gives us a great opportunity for unique creativity!

The good news is, popular original characters such as Winnie the Pooh and Alice in Wonderland are in the public domain, so not all is lost! :)